Close Dialog Window
Close Dialog Window
Shot From The Hip
Ruser Saldana
50comments The Tales We (Poorly) Weave
Posted Thu 26th Apr 2012 5:00pm by Ruser Saldana
Chuck Beaver's comments on Gears of War were harsh but much needed.
Chuck Beaver said that his comments on Gears of War were taken out of context, but saying that the game “contains atrocious, offensive violations of story basics” doesn’t strike me as context-sensitive. Even though Beaver later praised Gears of War, I think his opinion on its story is clear. Still, I wish he had publicly stood by his comments.
 
Here is a not-so-well-kept secret: videogame storytelling is bad. It is better now than it was 10 years ago, and there are a few games that have done it well (Bioshock, Shadow of the Colossus and Portal for example). But generally, it’s been a constant struggle for developers.
 
This is even true of games held in high regard. Beaver said that Gears has “literally, the worst writing in games” but Jill, the master of unlocking, might have something to say about that. By now, you’ve probably heard that Mass Effect 3 suffers from some plot holes and continuity issues. Skyrim (like Oblivion and other Bethesda RPGS before it) appears to go through great pains to make its narrative as boring as possible: must I read virtual books and silently stare at someone’s face as they statically talk at me?
 
  
The media can criticize and gamers can complain, but the most effective assessment of videogames comes from within the industry. That isn’t to say press and fans can't be influential; it’s just that the majority of us lack the forum and/or working knowledge of games to intelligently discuss what’s wrong with storytelling in videogames and how to fix it. On the other hand, people like Chuck Beaver have the opportunities, knowledge, and credibility that most media and gamers don’t.
 
Beaver’s opinions on Gears of War were harsh and not conducive to a dialogue about the problems with storytelling (to be fair, those comments weren’t made in an attempt to partake in such a discussion). Still, there’s value in someone within the industry calling attention to the issue in one of this generation’s most popular franchises.
 
In this case, he's talking about a series that doesn’t take its narrative too seriously, but that’s part of the problem. Was Epic Games simply too lax in their treatment of Gears’ story? Or did they just lack the ability to craft a proper one? Regardless, that a franchise can be so successful despite a poor narrative devalues the importance of storytelling (press is in part to blame for this: high review scores despite heavy story criticisms is a rampant problem). Yes, Gears of War is an action game largely focused on guns, shootouts, and explosions. But why do such games have lower writing standards than others?
 
Some, like Ken Levine, have shared their thoughts on storytelling, but it’s important that more people within the industry get involved: in a blog, an interview, at a trade show, whatever. If there’s going to be an improvement, it won’t simply be from publishers addressing media and consumer concerns. The industry must challenge itself and hold itself to a higher standard, and do so publicly so that their peers, gamers and the press can hold them accountable.
 
As for Beaver, I thought he was given a great opportunity to justify his comments and discuss the problems with Gears of War’s story. I was disappointed when he instead tried to take back his words. It was nice to see him jump into the discussion - a shame he decided to jump right back out.

Comment on this Article
Name:

E-Mail Address:
Will not be displayed to other users
Comments:

Verification:

Please enter the letters and numbers you see displayed in the above image.
The letters are not case sensitive.


Comments
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 28/05/2016 9:12am
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 28/05/2016 9:12am
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 22/05/2016 4:03pm
[b][url=http://www.rolexwatches.pw/no/]klokker pris[/url][/b] [b]klokker pklokker pris klokker pris klokker pris høy kvalitet Rolex kopier høy kvalitet Rolex kopier
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 22/05/2016 4:03pm
klokker pris klokker pris klokker pris klokker pris klokker pris klokker pris høy kvalitet Rolex kopier høy kvalitet Rolex kopier
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 21/05/2016 2:48am
[b][url=http://www.pradabagstore.top/no/]Prada poser[/url][/b][b][url=http://www.pradabagstore.top/no/]Prada håPrada poserPrada håndveskerPrada håndvesker salg Prada vesker outlet Prada Sale
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 21/05/2016 2:48am
Prada poserPrada håndveskerPrada håndvesker salg Prada poserPrada håndveskerPrada håndvesker salg Prada vesker outlet Prada Sale
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 07/05/2016 11:23pm
[b][url=http://www.undertexter.net/]swiss repliswiss replica watches aaa+ swiss replica watches
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 07/05/2016 11:23pm
high quality replica watches for men | watches | swiss Mechanical movement replica watches Replica PID 03624:Omega Constellation Automatic Diamond Man Size White Strap Watches - $227.00 : Professional replica watches stores, undertexter.net #sddm { margin: 0 auto; padding: 0; z-index: 30; background-color:#F4F4F4; width: 80px; height:23px; float: right; margin-right: 70px;} #sddm li { margin: 0; padding: 0; list-style: none; float: left; font: bold 12px arial} #sddm li a { display: block; margin: 0 1px 0 0; padding: 4px 10px; width: 60px; background: #f4762a; color: #666; text-align: center; text-decoration: none} #sddm li a:hover { background: #49A3FF} #sddm div { position: absolute; visibility: hidden; margin: 0; padding: 0; background: #EAEBD8; border: 1px solid #5970B2} #sddm div a { position: relative; display: block; margin: 0; padding: 5px 10px; width: auto; white-space: nowrap; text-align: left; text-decoration: none; background: #EAEBD8; color: #2875DE; font: 12px arial} #sddm div a:hover { background: #49A3FF; color: #FFF} Language Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 日本語 Russian Arabic Norwegian Swedish Danish Nederlands Finland Ireland English WELCOME TO REPLICA WATCHES STORES Sign In or Register Your cart is empty Omega Watches Rolex Watches Breitling Watches Currencies US Dollar Euro GB Pound Canadian Dollar Australian Dollar Jappen Yen Norske Krone Swedish Krone Danish Krone CNY Categories Replica U-Boat Replica Breitling Replica Longines Replica Omega Classic Constellation De Ville Hour Vision Ladymatic Mania Railmaster Seamaster Skeleton Speedmaster Replica Patek Philippe Replica Rado Replica Rolex Replica Watch Accessories Featured -   [more] Replica PID 00708:Breitling Chronomat Evolution Working Man Size Stainless Steel Strap Watches$749.00  $220.00Save: 71% offReplica PID 00704:Breitling Chronomat B01 Working Man Size Black Strap Watches$753.00  $230.00Save: 69% offReplica PID 00707:Breitling Chronomat Evolution Automatic Man Size Stainless Steel Strap Watches$813.00  $225.00Save: 72% off Home ::  Replica Omega ::  Constellation ::  Replica PID 03624:Omega Constellation Automatic Diamond Man Size White Strap Watches .jqzoom{ float:left; position:relative; padding:0px; cursor:pointer; width:301px; height:300px; } Replica PID 03624:Omega Constellation Automatic Diamond Man Size White Strap Watches $656.00  $227.00Save: 65% off Add to Cart: Description Welcome to replica watches outlet stores, the site for all your replica watches needs. The internet is full of vendors and sites trying to sell you replica watches and it isn't always easy finding the most reliable sites. We guarantee the best services with the best replica watches online. replica watches are everywhere, and it's important that you're getting the best available on the market today. Attributes Movement Asia Automatic Strap Material Stainless Steel Strap Colors White Dial Colors White Gender Man Size Weight 0.2kilogram Size Man Size(35 mm) The watch is driven by top quality Asia Automatic Movement (21 Jewel)The cheap watch has a solid 316 stainless steel case in high qualityThe dial is protected a sapphire crystal glassWater-ResistantThe seconds hand has a smooth sweeping motion rather than the usual jumpy tick-tockWe always make sure we check all our watches and pack our watches properly, bubble-wrapped before we ship them out. All orders are shipped either Related Products Replica PID 03824:Omega Constellation Automatic Stick Man Size Stainless Steel Strap Watches Replica PID 03813:Omega Constellation Co-Axial Man Size Stainless Steel Strap Watches Replica PID 03845:Omega Constellation Automatic Two Man Size Two Tone Strap Watches Replica PID 03634:Omega Seamaster Automatic Stick Man Size Stainless Steel Strap Watches Home Shipping Wholesale Order Tracking Coupons Payment Methods Contact Us REPLICA OMEGA REPLICA PATEK PHILIPPE REPLICA ROLEX REPLICA WATCHES REPLICA BREITLING Copyright © 2012-2015 All Rights Reserved. swiss replica watches aaa+ swiss replica watches
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 01/05/2016 10:20pm
reesebancr reesebancroft
51586 GK Points
Date Posted 01/05/2016 10:20pm
Page 1 of 5
>

Battlefield 3Review The GK Say Batman: Arkham CityReview The Awesomenauts AgendaInterview with Robin Meijer Gears of WarReview Child of EdenReview



Proud supporter of GamesAid
The Games Tribe
Game KudosCopyright © 2010 Game Kudos Ltd. All rights reserved.
By continuing use of this site, you agree to be bound by our Terms of Use and Acceptable Use Policy
Jobs @ GK | Advertising @ GK | PR @ GK |About Us | E-Mail Support | Acceptable Use Policy | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use